All Grown Up! Here's What Our Favorite Teen Heartthrobs Look Like Today


| LAST UPDATE 05/21/2023

By Christiana Holland

Thanks to Hollywood, we have been blessed with some of the most beloved characters on screen. Of course, we could never forget the famous faces of these iconic movies that were once plastered on our bedroom walls...

Jonathan Bennett

Our first teen heartthrob to kick things off is none other than Jonathan Bennett. However, most might recognize him as the iconic Aaron Samuels from North Shore High School! But now, he's completely off the market.

90s Heartthrob Before After90s Heartthrob Before After
Jean Paul Aussenard/WireImage/Rodin Eckenroth via Getty Images

Now 41 years old, we honestly don't know where the time has gone. It was just yesterday when Cady and Regina were fighting over this guy. But now, he's gone in a different direction. After dabbling in a few Hallmark Christmas films, he decided it was time to settle down and proposed to his boyfriend Jaymes Vaughan in 2020. So fetch!

Shane West

Just one glance and he had everyone hooked. There was once a time when we all wanted to be Mandy Moore in the arms of Landon Carter in A Walk To Remember. He stole the hearts of many but decided romance films weren't really his thing. He moved on to dominate thriller film-seekers and exceeded all of our expectations.

90s Heartthrob Before After90s Heartthrob Before After

His most recent film was Escape The Field, a thriller that was released in 2022. Yet, aside from his past and most current acting roles, West likes to reflect on his past on his Instagram profile. The flashback Fridays seem to be highly popular with his followers. We could say it's that touch of nostalgia everyone needs now and then!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Chad Michael Murray

Once upon a time, Chad Michael Murray was our Prince Charming and high school sweetheart wrapped in one. From dominating the One Tree Hill fan club, constantly trying to win over Rory in Gilmore Girls, and even setting the standard for all jocks in future romcoms after his Cinderella Story role, Murray had something special.

90s Heartthrob Before After90s Heartthrob Before After
Jeffrey Mayer/WireImage/Noel Vasquez via Getty Images

He has that same twinkle in his eye that he carried through the 2000s. Not to mention, his pearly whites and winning smile are enough to have us falling to the floor! But, sorry, folks, he is now taken. After living his TV dream of marrying Sophia Bush, he found true love with his wife, Sarah Roemer, who he married in 2015.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Jesse Metcalfe

Incoming: the ultimate playboy of the 2000s. For some reason, most of us wanted to date him despite his 2, 3, and 4-timing track record! Still, he managed to win us over. Despite making a few cameos in 2 Broke Girls, Desperate Housewives, and a few Hallmark Christmas specials, he is still remembered as the John Tucker.

90s Heartthrob Before After Metcalfe90s Heartthrob Before After Metcalfe
Jason Merritt/FilmMagic/Emily Assiran via Getty Images

So what has Metcalfe been getting up to these days? While he still might have the same looks and charm, give or take the facial hair, he definitely has the power to stay on our screens. Since departing from his bad boy era, Metcalfe has entered the world of drama. Since 2016, he has been a part of Chesapeake Shores as Trace Riley.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Jesse Bradford

It's our favorite electric guitar, rocking around the house, high school heartthrob. Let's be honest. There was nothing more intense than the chemistry between Cliff Pantone and Torrance Shipman. Those two were made for each other! It's the classic cheerleader meets the boy who is totally out of her league. Yet, we were here for it.

90s Heartthrob Before After Bradford90s Heartthrob Before After Bradford
Albert-L. Ortega/WireImage/Alberto E. Rodriguez via Getty Images

Since his big breakthrough in Bring It On, he hasn't been so prominent in the Hollywood scene as much. He might have wanted to leave it at that, just in case there wasn't any character that could beat Cliff. Instead, he has focused on being a family man with his daughter, born in 2021, and current equestrian girlfriend Andrea Watrouse.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Mark-Paul Gosselaar

This next guy had us distracted in class. Luckily we were saved by the bell! Every girl in high school history wished they were Kelly Kapowski. Mark Paul Gosselaar was the Justin Bieber of the 90s, with his very own distinct blonde bombshell hairstyle and a smile that was enchanting enough to break the fourth wall.

90s Heartthrob Before After Gosselaar90s Heartthrob Before After Gosselaar
Ron Galella Ltd./Ron Galella Collection/Marcus Ingram via Getty Images

He's still as dashing as ever. Although he might not be able to squeeze into his old Bayside bomber jacket, he's still full of talent. Since the NBC show, Gosselaar has appeared in Mixed-ish, Franklin & Bash, and the nostalgic reboot of Saved by the Bell. Not to mention, he has also become a family man now with 4 children!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Matt Dillon

Oh Matt Dillon. Are there any words to describe a jawline as sharp as his once was? He brought the Greased Lightning look to life with his bad-boy aesthetic yet he had a pure heart of gold. He was definitely up there in the list of swoon-worthy actors. From Drugstore Cowboy to cameos in Modern Family, he is a face to be reckoned with.

90s Heartthrob Before After Dillon90s Heartthrob Before After Dillon
Sunset Boulevard/Corbis/John Phillips via Getty Images

We have to give it to him. Despite the dad 'do and change of clothes, there's something about his smile which takes us back. After his teenage years, he went on to star in films such as There's Something About Mary, as well as the horror production of The House That Jack Built. The only thing scary about Dillon is his neverending charm.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Milo Ventimiglia

Milo Ventimiglia was everything that was anything taboo. While starring as Jess Mariano in Gilmore Girls, it's very clear why Rory eventually gave in, despite his devious antics. Still, his luscious brown locks and biker-boy image had everyone going crazy. He had that Italian stallion image that made hearts melt worldwide.

90s Heartthrob Before After Ventimiglia90s Heartthrob Before After Ventimiglia
Ron Davis/Rodin Eckenroth/WireImage via Getty Images

Guess what - he's still got it. Only now, he's rocking the dark-horse yet handsome aesthetic. His facial hair definitely adds ten points. Since his rodeo in the fictional town of Connecticut, he went on to star in the popular series, This Is Us, working alongside Mandy Moore. He just continues to wow us all, no matter what age.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Corbin Bleu

All the Wildcats gather around, we've got something special. We could recognize that curly hair-fro any day. The basketball star who adorned the halls of East High had his ways. Troy Bolton has his time, but there was something about Corbin which had us all jumping. He was the real down to earth deal. How could we forget that prom-posal?

90s Heartthrob Before After Bleu90s Heartthrob Before After Bleu
Michael Tran/FilmMagic/Rodin Eckenroth/WireImage via Getty Images

Since then, the High School Musical alum went on to star in other TV shows and films, such as Discovery Channel's Flight 29 Down, as well as another Disney original, Jump In! He still is in the industry today, despite the decades on him. We still love Mr. Bleu - and so does his wife, Sasha Clements!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Sean Faris

If Sean Faris isn't associated with the classic rom-com Sleepover, then what even is Sean Faris?! Jokes aside, Faris has set himself up to be the heartthrob for many teens around the world. Although it's no surprise that his fame rose after being nominated for prom King, no surprise.

90s Heartthrob Before After Faris90s Heartthrob Before After Faris
Dimitrios Kambouris/WireImage for Fingerprint Communications/Paul Archuleta via Getty Images

Today, he is the same charmer we all fell in love with back in the early 2000s. After all, he started to take his roles more seriously and starred in major drama series such as Pretty Little Liars as Gabriel Holbrook. Not to mention, he has been the love interest in a vast range of Hallmark movies - also a good reason to give them a watch.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Jordan Calloway

Talk about being totally Unfabulous? If Jordan Calloway doesn't ring a bell, then we don't know what will. Calloway might be predominantly remembered as Emma Roberts' high school bestie and basketball jock, Zach Carter-Schwartz. If the theme song wasn't running around our heads, it was Jordan Calloway.

90s Heartthrob Before After Calloway90s Heartthrob Before After Calloway
Toby Canham/Michael Loccisano via Getty Images

Since this was one of the most popular shows of the Nickelodeon prime era, it's always good to catch up with the gems from that time. Since then, he has veered into something more serious, playing Chuck Clayton in the early seasons of Riverdale. As well, he played the role of Khalil Payne in Black Lightning.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

Ever heard of the Stiff-Dylans? Well, this was their bass player. The renowned dreamboat Robbie was everything everyone cared about when Angus, Thongs, and Perfect Snogging hit theaters in 2008. His brown curls had us swooning. Plus, his appearance at Georgia's surprise party set the standard very high.

90s Heartthrob Before After Taylor-Johnson90s Heartthrob Before After Taylor-Johnson
Fred Duval/FilmMagic/Jun Sato/WireImage via Getty Images

Taylor-Johnson has continued to bless our screens. He was later cast in Kick-*ss and Kick-*ss 2, as well as the 2015 production of Avengers: Age of Ultron. His most recent star power was displayed in the 2022 film Bullet Train. Oh, and did we mention he met his wife on set at just 18 years old? (And they're still going strong today!)

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Tom Welling

Here's another teen heartthrob icon. Tom might just be one of the best things to come out of Midland, Indiana. He had the classic Bieber hair swoosh, but he did it his own way. His Smallville character, Charlie Baker, was a different type of jock - the quiet kind, which had us drooling from afar. And that red hat was iconic.

90s Heartthrob Before After Welling90s Heartthrob Before After Welling
Jeffrey Mayer/WireImage/Stefanie Keenan via Getty Images

Since leaving the Baker clan, Welling went on to act in the TV series Lucifer, which ran from 2016 until 2021. He seems to have a flare for action TV, as he also went on to star in the series Professionals. Aside from acting, he welcomed quite the love life after 2 marriages. Sadly, the silver fox is no longer on the market.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Matthew Lawrence

This face might be most recognized as one of the 3 children Mrs. Doubtfire looked after. While he rocked the classic oversized jacket and long hair, once he grew up, he only got more charming and handsome. While starring in Boy Meets World and Brotherly Love, Lawrence peaked as the perfect boyfriend to Rachel McAdams in The Hot Chick.

90s Heartthrob Before After Lawrence90s Heartthrob Before After Lawrence
Ron Galella Ltd./Ron Galella Collection/David Becker/WireImage via Getty Images

The camera loved him, and so did majority of every audience that tuned in to his teen sitcoms! Lawrence face lit up every room and scene. His most recent piece of work was playing Jimmy in Double Threat (2022). Thank goodness, we thought we saw the last of Lawrence! After a recent split from his ex-wife, he is now available, folks!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Adrian Grenier

We would do anything to be a part of Adrian Grenier's entourage. But, before his prime tv era, we really fell in love with Grenier when he was cast as Chase Hammond in Drive Me Crazy. This was perhaps the true stepping stone for our daydreams back in the day! We could say he was the total package with ultimate hair goals.

90s Heartthrob Before After Grenier90s Heartthrob Before After Grenier
George Pimentel/WireImage/Eugene Gologursky for CoinGeek via Getty Images

Grenier has continued to flaunt his blue eyes, which only complimented his locks even more. Although he might have played a controversial role in The Devil Wears Prada, we can't hold back the thought of dating him. Though, we won't be holding our breath, considering he tied the knot to girlfriend Jordan Roemmele this past summer...

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Rob Lowe

Rob Lowe has always had baby blue eyes and hair that could outshine anyone walking out of a hair salon. Those curls were all natural and swept tons of ladies off their feet. He made his mark as Sodapop Curtis in The Outsiders. There wasn't anything that bomber jacket and piercing stare couldn't do.

90s Heartthrob Before After Lowe90s Heartthrob Before After Lowe
Sergio Gaudenti/Sygma/David Livingston via Getty Images

Although his character was fairly dysfunctional, he and Matt Dillon were a shoo-in for the film's heartthrobs. Since then, his eyes have stayed just as captivating, yet the locks have been trimmed. After making appearances in Californication and The Interview, he has devoted a special amount of time to his wife and 2 children.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Omar Epps

So when was the exact moment we knew we were going to be dreaming about Mr. Epps? Well, it was that defined shirtless scene in Love & Basketball. The 2000s was certainly a time to be alive. Not to mention, it's no surprise there was a surge in basketball fans during these golden years. We can only blame the First Time Felon star...

90s Heartthrob Before After Epps90s Heartthrob Before After Epps
Ron Galella, Ltd./Ron Galella Collection/Sean Zanni for STARZ via Getty Images

Since his 2000 debut, Epps went on to star in major movie roles as well as hit television series such as This Is Us. After appearing in Dracula and Scream 2, he was also cast in the series ER. It's quite clear why he had so many patients. Plus, he's a double whammy - a big movie star, and also the dream husband to singer Keisha!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Freddie Prinze Jr.

Freddie Prinze Jr. was all that. The jock jacket, the classic 2000 spiked haircut, and the dashing smile to match his playboy facade. Underneath that persona, we knew there was a softie deep down. He had it all - president of the class, captain of the team, and even won the girl, making one of the top heartthrobs of the generation!

90s Heartthrob Before After Prinze Jr.90s Heartthrob Before After Prinze Jr.
Ron Galella Ltd./Ron Galella Collection/Vincent Sandoval via Getty Images

She's All That was definitely a peak moment of his career. Since then, he went along to star in a range of ultra-happy films to keep the ball rolling. While he starred as Freddie Jones in the Scoopy Doo films, he also went on to star in Jack and Jill, Summer Catch, and finally, Christmas With You. He was what we all wanted for Christmas!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Donald Faison

Faison might not have been the lead in Clueless, but his scenes were simply the best. Playing Dionne's complicated love interest, Murray, he proved his innocence once he let his ego go. Despite Clueless, he also made his mark in Rememeber The Titans after going shirtless in the locker room. A moment to always remember.

90s Heartthrob Before After Faison90s Heartthrob Before After Faison
Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection/Corey Nickols for IMDb via Getty Images

He was everything we loved about the 90s. But we all grew up, and he turned over to more serious roles. Faison, out the many others, romanticized his doctor character in Scrubs. He also made an aca-awesome appearance in Pitch Perfect. Aside from acting, he too went on to become a family man, now the father to 6 children!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

James Van Der Beek

Hold your horses. James Van Der Beek had long blonde hair like a soft horse's mane. It was the tee shirt that also added a little something to his boy-next-door aesthetic. He was the ultimate country boy of Dawson's Creek, playing the one and only, Dawson. Safe to say, he made us swoon.

90s Heartthrob Before After Van Der Beek90s Heartthrob Before After Van Der Beek
Handout Bruce Glikas/FilmMagic via Getty Images

Since exiting the creek, Beek entered the world of One Tree Hill and fellow 90s teen show Varsity Blues. He just had the look. While he grew out of his heartthrob phase, Van Der Beek took on a series of action films such as Texas Rangers and Taken in Broad Daylight, all while he was taking care of his kiddies at home!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Jared Leto

We're not joking when we say Jared Leto was the ultimate bad boy that we wanted to know. He was the kind of kid most fans wanted to cut class with, and it was definitely worth it. There must be something hypnotizing in those deep blue eyes. Thankfully, to this day, he could still play that same sassy teenager.

90s Heartthrob Before After Leto90s Heartthrob Before After Leto
Jim Smeal/Ron Galella Collection/Axelle-Bauer Griffin/FilmMagic via Getty Images

We grew a different kind of love for Leto when he grew out his hair and played with color. There's something adventurous about him, which is most likely why he is keeping the fans alive. His quirky character yet charming looks have landed him roles in infamous productions, romanticizing his edgy characters. We aren't complaining, though!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Leonardo DiCaprio

Little Leo was an up-and-coming actor the minute producers laid eyes on him. The blonde hair, the blue eyes, and the cheeky smile. He had it all. That being said, his 360 personas landed him major roles from a young age, such as The Boy's Life and Total Eclipse. Of course, since then, he has become famous for the Wolf of Wall Street.

90s Heartthrob Before After DiCaprio90s Heartthrob Before After DiCaprio
Ron Davis/Kevin Mazur for Netflix via Getty Images

It breaks out hearts to know it took Leo so long to win that well-deserved Oscar. But they say good things come to those who wait. As he continues to work in the industry, this hasn't just landed him major movie roles but also younger girlfriends. Let's just say Leo has made quite the roster. Not that we're judging, of course!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Jason Priestley

Another Beverly Hills 90210 heartthrob: speaking of eyes, take a load of Jason's back in the day! From the late 90s until the early 2000s, Priestly had a special place in our hearts. From hitting the road with Calendar Girl to being our one True Angel, he was definitely a sight for sore eyes.

90s Heartthrob Before After Priestley90s Heartthrob Before After Priestley
Robert Scott/Fotos International/Stephane Cardinale Corbis/Corbis via Getty Images

We have to give it to Priestly, as he still has that same twinkle in his eye that the Kodak film captured back in the day. His most recent piece of work can be seen in the TV series Private Eyes, where he plays Matt Shade, as well as the festive film, Dear Christmas playing Chris Massey. But he will always be our Fitz.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Luke Perry

It seems anyone who came out of 90210 was bound to be remembered. One man, in particular, was Luke Perry. He was the epitome of Beverly Hills 90210, which is when he became the teen idol for many folks out there aiming to win over the girl of their dreams. He truly was one to be reckoned with - a sweetheart on and off the screen.

90s Heartthrob Before After Perry90s Heartthrob Before After Perry
Newsmakers/JB Lacroix/WireImage via Getty Images

After becoming a 90s heartthrob, Perry's name was typically associated with 90210 - although he also appeared in Buffy The Vampire Slayer. In 2019, he was cast in Tarantino's Once Upon A Time In Hollywood, leaving a great mark in film history. Sadly, the actor passed in 2019 - but left behind an amazing legacy and 2 children.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

Joseph Gordon-Levitt has made it clear he's not letting anyone forget about him. From a young age, his adorable smile and perfectly sleeked hair stole our hearts from the second we saw him in 3rd Rock From The Sun. After that, he powered through a series of characters, making him a complete icon.

90s Heartthrob Before After Levitt90s Heartthrob Before After Levitt
Scott Gries/David Livingston via Getty Images

Not only has the Don-Jon lover boy barely aged over time, but he has kept up the fan hype! That's not so easy to do when you're in the industry 35+ years. Even now, without the long locks, we are still swooning over his films. Still, all we can think about is his adorable nerdy character from 10 Things I Hate About You.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Andrew Keegan

Those might just be the brownest eyes we've ever seen. For most, Andrew Keegan had a face carved by angels. His major role was in 10 Things I Hate About You, and he mainly dabbled in the industry through the 90s and early 2000s. He appeared in The Hot Chick, the original Freaky Friday, as well as TV series 7th Heaven.

90s Heartthrob Before After Keegan90s Heartthrob Before After Keegan
SGranitz./WireImage/Paul Archuleta via Getty Images

However, he devoted his acting career to his years in the 90s and early 2000s. Since then, he has ditched the cameras and tapped into a more spiritual side. In 2014, news broke that Keegan had started his own religion and began to lead a group of anyone who followed his beliefs. Yet, he remains to do this in the heart of California.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Mario Lopez

Another total jock who swept us off our feet was A.C. Slater from Bayside High. The other half of Zach Morris was underrated at the time. Although he stole the heart of Jessie Spano and occasionally Kelly Kapowski, he was always a winner in our eyes! We think it was his curly hair that did the trick.

90s Heartthrob Before After Lopez90s Heartthrob Before After Lopez
Ron Galella Ltd./Ron Galella Collection/Frazer Harrison/WireImage via Getty Images

The Saved By the Bell star made quite a career for himself. While he appeared in both Honey films, he also went on to show off his skills in Dancing with the Stars and co-host the X Factor USA. We're just jealous of his kids who can say that A.C Slater is their dad!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Rider Strong

Meet Rider Strong. He was Shawn, the side-kick lover boy beside Cory Mathews throughout the hit teen series of the 90s, Boy Meets World. We can't argue that Shawn went down as one of the most iconic best friends in sitcom history. We think it was the hair - and he didn't let us forget about it.

90s Heartthrob Before After Strong90s Heartthrob Before After Strong
Ron Wolfson/Michael Ochs Archives/David Becker for iHeartRadio via Getty Images

Since then, Strong went on to continue his Shawn legacy in the Disney Channel reboot Girl Meets World. He came back as the savvy 'uncle' to Cory and Topanga's daughter, Riley. Though he experimented in other films throughout the late 90s, we think his heart belongs to the BMW clan. He still has that mischievous smile today.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

Last but not least, we have Mr. Taylor Thomas. Let's just say he had some simple rules to live by: always have the hair looking good... and always hold a puppy!? While acting in Man of the House and 8 Simple Rules, those eyes had us hypnotized. His teen characters always displayed that cheeky boy-next-door kind of guy.

90s Heartthrob Before After Taylor Thomas90s Heartthrob Before After Taylor Thomas
Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic Inc/GTStar Max/FilmMagic via Getty Images

In 1998, he left Home Improvement to focus on his academics. Now 41 years old, Thomas officially left acting behind and hasn't looked back. "He really was dedicated to his studies, and then kind of got away from TV.," fellow co-star Tim Allen recalled to Yahoo. We respect it!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below


MMMBop! Would ya take a look at these guys? The iconic boy band that started in the 90s started a whole new music cult. What's ironic is that they were simply a group of 3 brothers from Tulsa who loved music and started fooling around. Little did they know their one-track hit and long hair would have fans going crazy.

90s Heartthrob Before After Hanson90s Heartthrob Before After Hanson
Tim Roney/Rebecca Sapp for The Recording Academy via Getty Images

Was there a Hanson hairstyle? Well, if there was, we wanted it! The group had fun dabbling around in the studio, creating tracks up until the mid-2000s - as well as 2017, when they brought out a Christmas track. But, most importantly, they are now surrounded by loving families and have even started a tour for the band's 25th anniversary.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below